Avoid these 3 valuation mistakes when applying for a home loan

A lender's valuation determines how much you can borrow, whether you pay LMI, and sometimes what rate you receive.

The valuation figure matters more than the purchase price once your application reaches credit assessment. A shortfall between contract price and assessed value leaves you with three choices: increase your deposit, negotiate the price down, or walk away. For legal professionals with structured income verification and salary packaging arrangements, the valuation component is often the only variable you cannot control through documentation. Most valuation issues arise not from overpriced properties but from misunderstanding how lenders assess value and when to request a review.

Relying on the Contract Price as the Borrowing Basis

Lenders calculate your loan amount and LVR using the lower of the purchase price and the lender's assessed valuation. If you agree to pay $950,000 and the valuer assesses the property at $920,000, your LVR is calculated on $920,000 regardless of what you are contractually obliged to pay. A 10% deposit on the contract price suddenly becomes insufficient if the valuation falls short, and you may be required to fund the difference or pay LMI where you had budgeted to avoid it.

Consider a barrister purchasing an apartment in Pyrmont with a contract price of $875,000 and a planned deposit of $175,000 to achieve an 80% LVR. The lender's valuation comes back at $850,000. The LVR is now approximately 82.4%, triggering an LMI premium that was not originally factored into settlement costs. The buyer can either increase the cash deposit to $170,000 to restore the 80% LVR on the lower valuation, or proceed with LMI and absorb the premium. In both scenarios, the shortfall must be resolved before settlement.

This issue occurs more frequently in precincts with rapid price movement or limited comparable sales. Pyrmont's mix of older low-rise stock and newer high-density towers creates valuation complexity, particularly where a property has been renovated or reconfigured in ways that differ from recent sales in the same building. Valuers typically draw comparables from a three to six month window. If your purchase reflects a price increase that has occurred in the last few weeks and has not yet been captured in settled sales data, the valuation may not reflect that uplift.

Assuming All Valuations Are Equivalent Across Lenders

Each lender engages its own panel of valuers, and two valuers can reasonably arrive at different figures for the same property. Valuation is not a precise science. It combines recent sales data, adjustments for condition and location, and professional judgement about market direction. A variance of 5% between two desktop valuations on the same property is not unusual, particularly in areas with diverse housing stock or where recent sales are limited.

In our experience, a physical inspection generally results in a more accurate and often higher valuation than a desktop assessment, but not all lenders will automatically send a valuer to site. Desktop valuations rely on sales data, property records, and sometimes street view imagery. They are faster and lower cost, but they cannot account for renovations, aspect, internal condition, or other factors that affect value but are not visible in public records. If your property has been recently updated or has features that distinguish it from comparable sales, a physical inspection may produce a materially different result.

If you receive a valuation that appears inconsistent with recent sales, you can request a review or seek a second opinion. Some lenders allow you to provide additional comparables or supporting information as part of a formal reconsideration process. Where the valuation appears to be an outlier, switching to a different lender with a different valuer panel may be more efficient than attempting to negotiate the original figure. This decision should be made early in the process, as switching lenders after a valuation has been ordered may result in additional fees and delays. If you are concerned about valuation risk on a specific property, discussing loan pre-approval options with a broker before signing a contract allows you to identify potential issues while you still have negotiating flexibility.

Not Addressing Valuation Shortfalls Before Settlement

A valuation shortfall does not automatically disqualify your application, but it does require a response. The lender will not proceed to settlement until the LVR is reconciled with their assessed figure. Ignoring the issue or assuming the lender will overlook a small variance is not a viable strategy. If the valuation comes in below the contract price, your options are limited and time-sensitive.

You can increase your deposit to restore the intended LVR, negotiate a price reduction with the vendor, or accept a higher LVR and pay LMI if that option is available. Legal professionals may have access to LMI waivers depending on their level of seniority and the lender's policy, which can reduce the cost impact of a higher LVR. However, LMI waivers typically apply up to 90% LVR, and a valuation shortfall that pushes the loan beyond that threshold may still require additional deposit funds even where a partial waiver applies.

In scenarios where the shortfall is material and cannot be resolved through negotiation, you may need to consider whether the property remains viable or whether the contract should be terminated under the cooling-off or finance clause provisions. A finance clause is only effective if it is correctly drafted and the valuation issue is identified and disclosed within the specified timeframe. Once the finance clause expires, your options narrow considerably, and you may face forfeiture of the deposit if you are unable to settle.

Valuation shortfalls are more common in off-the-plan purchases and house and land packages, where the contract price is agreed well in advance of settlement and market conditions may shift in the interim. If you are purchasing a house and land package, confirm with your broker whether the lender will conduct a pre-construction valuation based on plans or whether valuation will occur at practical completion. The timing affects how early you will know if a shortfall exists and how much flexibility you have to address it.

Property valuation is a procedural step, but it directly affects loan structure, deposit requirements, and settlement timing. Preparing for valuation risk before signing a contract and understanding your reconsideration rights after a valuation is completed are both part of managing the application process with precision.

Call one of our team or book an appointment at a time that works for you.

Frequently Asked Questions